Games

This Is The Darkest Moment Of The Penguin

Published

1 month ago

November 22, 2024

Christoph Rediske

The following article contains spoilers for The Penguin Season 1 on HBO Max

Key Takeaways

Table of Contents

Oz goes from likable protagonist to psychopathic antagonist quickly, showcasing his dark descent.
The scene where Oz sends Sofia back to Arkham instead of killing her is the darkest moment in The Penguin.
The most heart-wrenching scene in The Penguin is when Oz strangles Vic, emphasizing his ruthless nature.

Now that The Penguin‘s entire series is available for watchability by anyone with a subscription to HBO Max, there are plenty of big moments to see. The Penguin offers several moments that are more than a little newsworthy, all leading up to Oz Cobb’s rise as the kingpin of Gotham. In order to make an omelet, Oz knew he had to break some eggs. He had to go very, very dark after spending most of the series being a kind of protagonist. It even seemed like the show was going to have some problems reminding people that he was a bad guy.

However, it took no time at all to make people realize that actually, Oz really was a bad guy. He went from likable to psychopath pretty quickly. And he had some really dark moments. It wasn’t just when he was an adult, either. The part where a young Oz killed his brothers so that only he could get his mother’s love was a striking scene in the HBO Max show. It started to show that the man was never really a good person. He always had something wrong. And then, the finale especially showed just how bad he was in the head. However, the moment that most people see as the darkest moment of the show was, in fact, not the darkest moment in the show.

No One Even Mentions Batman In The Penguin & That Makes Perfect Sense

There’s been no sign of Pattinson’s Batman in the new spinoff, but the plot of the first movie explains the character’s absence.

Oz Reaches New Evil In The Penguin Finale

When talking about the darkest, most heart wrenching scene in The Penguin, most people are going to arrive at the moment when Oz strangles Vic. That’s not a surprise, especially because of what led up to that moment.

Showrunner Advertisement	Lauren LeFranc
Stars	Colin Farrell, Cristin Milioti, Rhenzy Feliz, Deirdre O’Connell
Episodes	8 Advertisement
Release Dates	September 19, 2024–November 10, 2024
Streaming On	HBO Max

Vic and Oz are sitting alone having just won the mob war and become a real Batman & Robin of crime. They are a mirror image of Bruce Wayne and any of his three wards that came and went over the years. Their plan was almost perfect and allowed Oz to escape any number of dangers as the plan was executed in order to be the victor.

Not only that but Vic had just finished talking about how he felt like Oz was his family. How they could be together and rise to the top of the crime world. Vic thought theirs was a partnership that’s could last. And then Oz decided he had to kill him precisely because he also thought of his young protege as a family member. That was what made the moment really dark. It wasn’t that Vic was wrong about their relationship it was that he was right and Oz couldn’t have that. It was essentially a repeat of what he did to his brothers when he was younger. He needed to be at the top all by himself. He couldn’t have anyone taking up room. And so he killed the kid who had been his most loyal ally throughout the show.

The scene was sufficiently dark and foreboding. It did the job it set out to do. But it wasn’t the darkest scene in The Penguin. That scene belonged to Oz’s final scene with Sofia Falcone. That might surprise some because he left her live. But that was the point.

Sometimes Death Is A Mercy

Sometimes in a show like The Penguin, fans realize that being killed isn’t the worst thing that can happen to a character. When Sofia and Oz see their relationship come to a head and the two are talking like they’re saying goodbye forever, it’s assumed that Oz is going to kill the woman who was the only person who was really in his way in his climb to the top.

The scene is set up to look like so many other mob movies and mob television shows where the mob boss is leading out a victim to the middle of nowhere in order to kill them. Sofia certainly thinks that’s what’s about to go down. Instead, Oz has set her up to be the fallguy. She’s the person the police are looking for to pin the Hangman murders on. And with the fact that she really did kill her entire family and was suspected of that crime, it’s not hard for Gotham’s finest to make that case stick.

So, instead of Oz killing Sofia, he effectively sends her back to the place she hates more than anything the place that brings back so much trauma that she appears to be catatonic when we see her back in Arkham. She is effectively in hell. It’s a safe bet that she would have preferred to be killed than sent back to the place that transformed her into the person who was capable of killing her entire family.

That’s why the scene showing the final exchange between Oz and Sofia is really the darkest scene in The Penguin. Because he knows how damaging that is to her. She told him several different times during the series just how much of a nightmare being stuck in Arkham was. He knew that, and he went out of his way to do it to her, when he could have just killed her. There was no need to pin the Hangman murders on her at this point in the story. She was dealt with. And he once again, took the most evil avenue possible.

Created by Lauren LeFranc and starring Colin Farrell, The Penguin builds on 2022’s The Batman. The Max series chronicles the eponymous villain’s attempt to reach Gotham’s criminal peak, rising through the underworld in the middle of a power struggle.