The Best Horror Games That Mess With Your Mind

Given how massive the horror video game scene is, it’s no surprise that it doesn’t follow a ‘one-size-fits-all’ formula. Horror has always been a fan-favorite genre, with probably more game releases than most other categories, but despite how active developers are in creating horror games, only a select few titles really stand out and make a lasting impact.

Some of the best horror games in the industry don’t follow the typical horror format, which includes the most uncalled-for jumpscares, unnecessarily loud and generic horror music, and immensely predictable plot twists. Instead, they go with the more subtle approach and gradually aim towards a banging reveal as the game progresses. The understated nature of these games is exactly what messes with the player’s minds and is far more effective than some of the more traditional horror games out there.

9 Reveil

A Circus-Themed Game With Many Hidden Plot Points

Reveil is a 2024 first-person indie psychological thriller that tries to push the boundaries of all things psychological and ends up pulling it off pretty well. It follows the life of a circus stage builder, Walter Thompson, and his strange relationship with his family — which is essentially the central conflict of the entire game.

Reveil is what the artistic people would call a “surreal masterpiece.” It starts off in the most absurd, dream-like setting, and continuously shifts between reality and dream (or more appropriately, nightmare), making the player question what is real and what is not. The plot line related to the main character’s family, and his mysterious past as a part of a circus, somehow merge together for a grand reveal at the end. Everything the player interacts with, and every choice they make throughout the game, works towards an outrageously unexpected ending.

8 Baby Blues Nightmare

A First-Person Horror From The Lens Of A Toddler

Horror games are already, well, horrifying to begin with, but having a child protagonist just adds a deeper layer of vulnerability and helplessness that usually elevates the games’ psychological aspects. Baby Blues Nightmare is a first-person horror adventure played entirely from the lens of a toddler navigating through a world of horrors.

The game is very similar to Among the Sleep, and plays on the “everything is too big for the child main character” idea, where the toddler has to essentially work their way through their own nightmares. There’s a little stealth involved in the gameplay, where players have to prevent the from crying by doing different “happy” tasks, like eating chocolates or playing. The more scared and sad the character is, the more likely they’re going to cry, and will ultimately be more prone to getting caught by some freakish monsters.

7 Doki Doki Literature Club

A Seemingly Normal Visual Novel That Breaks So Many Cliches

While some gamers might have strict criteria for what qualifies as a game, often excluding visual novels, there are a few that manage to break that mold. Doki Doki Literature Club is a seemingly normal and harmless dating sim/visual novel that initially does not feel like a revolutionary game made to be groundbreaking for the genre — until the twist.

Doki Doki Literature Club starts off as any cutesy visual novel and dating sim would; with an unnamed main character surrounded by a group of girls that may or may not potentially end up as his love interest. The protagonist is forced into a high school literature club by his childhood best friend and potential love interest, Sayori. His slow but steady interaction with each member of the literature club influences his relationship with them — until it doesn’t. The game eventually leans into its reality and turns into a psychological horror with extensive breaking of the fourth wall, and certain plot lines that leave everyone shocked and appalled.

6 Dead Space

A First-Person Shooter With A Major Reveal

Dead Space can be considered one of the quintessential survival horror games to explore the “unexpected grand reveal” format that leaves players unnerved and questioning everything they’ve played. It’s a horror sci-fi third-person shooter that revolves around alien-like monsters, futuristic combat mechanics, and post-disaster settings, with little to no allusion towards a unique existential ending.

Dead Space follows Isaac Clarke, a spaceship engineer, who’s assigned a mission to the now-defunct USG Ishimura planetcracker ship that is conducting some sort of illegal mining on a faraway planet. For Isaac, despite his official position as the lead engineer, this mission is very personal, since his girlfriend, Nicole, was a senior medical officer on the Ishuimura, and is now missing. Throughout the game, the only connection Isaac has with Nicole is through a series of eerie messages and hallucinations, where she offers guidance as he navigates the horrors of the ship. The truth of these messages will shock every player the first time around.

5 Layers Of Fear

Non-Combat Action-Adventure With A Prominent Psychological Element

Horror shooters, no matter how psychologically twisted, eventually end up feeling slightly meek because of the security players feel through their weapons and arsenal. Games like Amnesia and Layers of Fear innately provide a feeling of dread for their players because of how non-violent they are, at least from the player character’s point of view.

Layers of Fear is a 2016 narrative-driven horror adventure that follows the story of a painter on a journey to create his magnum opus — something that he’s worked all his life for. Naturally, as certain artists are, The Painter dedicates his entire life, dreams, and sanity to creating his masterpiece, and basically sidelines everything else. This eventually bleeds into his personal life and drives him to make some questionable decisions. The gameplay revolves around said painter traveling around an old Victorian house and finding unsettling clues and inspirations to complete his painting.

4 Eternal Darkness

Open Use Of A Sanity Meter To Keep The MC’s Mind In Check

Eternal Darkness is a 2002 action-adventure game, and one of the first few games that very openly utilizes the “sanity meter” gameplay mechanic. While this may sound like a common idea in today’s gaming landscape, it was quite revolutionary for Eternal Darkness back in 2002, setting a new standard for psychological elements in video games.

The game is basically a set of interconnected stories that play out into one main timeline. The first playable character, Alex, finds herself in the middle of a mysterious situation connected to her grandfather’s murder and a seemingly occult book. The book, known as “The Tome of Eternal Darkness”, contains various dark stories related to a large-scale power struggle between godlike beings known as the Ancients and their minions. She goes through these stories in succession, and eventually finds out her own prime purpose in the timeline.

3 Inscryption

A Deck-Building Game That Messes With The Mind In Unexpected Ways

Advertisement

With most games on this list being action-adventure or survival horror, a deck-building puzzle game may come off as an unexpected surprise, especially in the horror genre. However, with Inscryption‘s very unique and ingenious gameplay, it makes sense. It’s a 2021 card game that blends the most unique genres, including roguelikes, tabletop games, and escape rooms, and comes away with a masterpiece.

Inscryption‘s story, despite how immersive and brain-intensive it is, is still shrouded in mysterious and cryptic plot lines. Most of the time, players don’t know what they’re working towards, or if there is even an end goal or grand reveal. The slow building towards imminent doom, the unnerving card designs (and characterizations), and the almost life-and-death situation presented in every game against the not-so-friendly gamemaster creates an atmosphere that’s hard to shake off, even after the game’s over.

2 Amnesia: The Dark Descent

A Survival Game That Genuinely Builds Towards Organic Fear

Amnesia: The Dark Descent is another survival horror entry that can be considered a standout for having some of the most effectively scary horror sequences in the genre. The game employs almost all the subtly mind-bending and disorienting tactics used in horror and successfully creates a game that succeeds at far more than its initial impressions suggest.

Amnesia revolves around Daniel, a man with, well, amnesia, who wakes up in a strange gothic castle that has more to it than meets the eye. The only detail Daniel remembers about his life is that he’s not safe, and is being stalked by someone or something. Players, as Daniel, feel that impending doom slowly creeping up on them, and can feel Daniel’s palpable fear and confusion throughout the course of their castle expedition. The game works towards creating an atmosphere that doesn’t depend on jump scares or generic B-type horror sequences but aims to create organic fear out of soundtracks, character stories, and terrifying escape sequences as the helpless Daniel has only two means of defense: hide, or run.

1 Silent Hill 2

The Most Revolutionary Reality-Warping Horror Game Ever Created

Advertisement

The entire Silent Hill franchise is celebrated for its symbolism, intricate storytelling, and intense climactic endings. However, like many franchises, it has a standout title — Silent Hill 2. Released in 2001, Silent Hill 2 is not only revolutionary in its premise, but also groundbreaking for its impressive graphics, which pushed the boundaries of what was possible for a video game at the time.

Silent Hill 2 tells the story of James Sunderland, a man who receives a cryptic letter from his dead wife that leads him to the town of Silent Hill. As James navigates the ghost town, he encounters various characters and creatures that creatively reflect his own psychological turmoil. The subtlety of certain actions, combined with the overall immersive experience, allows players to genuinely feel like they’re stepping into James’ shoes, blurring the line between character and player.