Games

One Piece: Carrot Deserves Better

Published

3 weeks ago

December 2, 2024

Christoph Rediske

Key Takeaways

Table of Contents

Carrot, an important character in One Piece, was left behind without a proper goodbye, disappointing fans.
Carrot’s significant contributions and emotional journey with the Straw Hats deserved a better send-off.
In the anime, Carrot was given a non-canon farewell, but fans still feel unsatisfied with her story’s conclusion.

One Piece, as a story, features so many characters that it’s hard to keep track of. From the residents of Orange Town in the East Blue to the children of Punk Hazard, all the way to the various groups scattered throughout the Land of Wano, at times it can be difficult to keep track of every character at every point of the story. Due to this, unfortunately, at times, characters that the One Piece fanbase thought would be important are instead left behind and forgotten.

However, at times, integral characters that were once extremely important to the story of One Piece have been forgotten as well. One character specifically has had the fanbase up in arms, with many believing that they deserved far better. This character, Carrot, felt like an honorary Straw Hat crew member but was left behind by the story faster than any other.

An Up-To-Date One Piece Game Would Be At Odds With One Character

Whenever a new One Piece video game arrives, it will need to give one villain special treatment normally reserved for the heroes.

Carrot of One Piece’s Minx Tribe

Optimism and Power

Carrot’s Introduction Advertisement	Chapter 804; Episode 753
Straw Hats Leaving Wano	Chapter 1057, Episode 1084

Carrot was first introduced to the story after the events of Dressrosa, during One Piece’s Zou Arc. Being a part of the Minx Tribe, Carrot is a young, rabbit-humanoid and a member of Duke Dogstrom’s Musketeer Squad. Due to this, she has fairly substantial combat capabilities and can hold her own against strong opponents.

However, as the Straw Hats left Zou for One Piece’s Whole Cake Island, Carrot secretly joined the Sanji Retrieval Team, following after her idol, Pedro. From here, Carrot was an important member of the Straw Hat team, helping save the group on multiple occasions. Additionally, even after Whole Cake Island, Carrot continued to help the Straw Hats during their time in the Land of Wano.

The Straw Hats Don’t Say Goodbye to Carrot

Left On Wano

Carrot screaming with her hands in the air

However, despite everything that the One Piece Minx, Carrot, did for the crew, at the end of the Wano Arc, the Straw Hats left her behind without so much as a goodbye. Despite saying goodbye to Kin’emon and Momonosuke, Carrot doesn’t even receive a thank you for the amount of time and effort she put in. For many, this was a disappointing send-off for a character many considered to be an honorary member of the Straw Hat crew.

But there are so many people who are way stronger than me! – Carrot to the Minx Tribe

This is especially disappointing due to the amount that Carrot did during their adventures. Without Carrot awakening her Sulong form, the Straw Hats would have easily been captured by One Piece Emperor, Big Mom. Additionally, during Whole Cake Island, Carrot witnessed her mentor and idol, Pedro, sacrifice himself in order to give the rest of the group a better chance of escaping. From the amount of physical and emotional trauma that Carrot went through in her time with the Straw Hats, a simple goodbye would have gone a long way.

New Photos Of Eiichiro Oda At The Set Of One Piece Live Action Surface Online

The latest set of photos shows Eiichiro Oda in Cape Town.

Even outside the story, Carrot has been with the Straw Hat crew over a significant amount of real-world time, slowly becoming one of the fanbase’s most beloved characters. Since her introduction in 2015, Carrot stuck around with the crew for over half a decade. Seeing such an important character vanish without another interaction with the Straw Hats feels like a disservice to fans.

The Anime Gives a Non-Cannon Farewell

Too Little, Too Late

Despite not receiving a canon send-off in the manga, in the One Piece anime, Carrot was actually given a proper goodbye during a filler episode at the end of Wano. However, despite this moment, many fans are still sad about the character’s improper send-off, which explains away her need to explore the seas as already being fulfilled from her adventures with the Straw Hats. Whether with the goodbye from the Straw Hats or not, Carrot returns to the Minx Tribe to become the new leader of the group, ultimately ending her career as a pirate.

In the end, it’s sad to see such a beloved character left behind by the world of One Piece. Although Carrot joining the Straw Hats would probably be a step too far, seeing a better ending to the character’s story as we know it would have been plenty to satisfy fans. However, the story of One Piece isn’t over yet. Carrot still has plenty of time to return and give fans the satisfying send-off they wanted.